Merge docs/sim-automation

docs/SIMULATOR-AUTOMATION.md

@@ -0,0 +1,486 @@
+# iOS Simulator UI Automation Guide
+
+> Empirically verified on: iPhone 12 mini (iOS 18.6), Xcode 16.4, macOS Intel  
+> UDID: `062F8F0A-B3E5-4A4B-BC8A-B01E98CF27F2`  
+> App: `de.vpsj.pi-remote` (URL scheme: `pi-remote://`)
+
+---
+
+## TL;DR
+
+**Use Facebook's `idb` (idb_companion + idb CLI).** It talks to the simulator
+via gRPC, reads the full accessibility tree to find elements by label/ID, and
+provides tap, swipe, text-input, key, and screenshot primitives — all without
+knowing window coordinates ahead of time and without touching the app source.
+
+---
+
+## Approach Comparison Table
+
+| Method | What it can do | Pros | Cons | Verified? |
+|---|---|---|---|---|
+| **idb** (fb-idb + idb_companion) | tap, swipe, text input, keys, describe-all, screenshot | Full accessibility tree; no coordinate guessing; no app changes needed; free CLI | idb Python client needs Python ≤3.12 venv; older companion (Aug 2022) but still works on iOS 18 | ✓ YES |
+| `xcrun simctl io screenshot` | screenshot only | Built-in, no install | Only screenshots + video; no input | ✓ YES (limited) |
+| `xcrun simctl ui` | appearance/contrast/font-size | Built-in | Zero UI element interaction | ✓ YES (limited) |
+| `xcrun simctl openurl` | open URL scheme | Built-in; NO confirm prompt | Can't tap buttons or assert UI | ✓ YES |
+| `xcrun simctl privacy` | grant/revoke permissions | Bypasses permission dialogs | No interaction | ✓ YES |
+| `xcrun simctl push` | send push notifications | Built-in | No UI interaction | ✓ YES |
+| `xcodebuild test` + XCUITest | everything | Official Apple, most powerful | Requires test target in Xcode project; heavyweight; can't add test target to existing app without source changes | ✗ NOT TESTED (requires source changes) |
+| WebDriverAgent / Appium | everything | Cross-platform, widely used | Complex setup; requires WDA compiled for simulator; gRPC port juggling | ✗ NOT TESTED |
+| AppleScript / System Events | host-OS window automation | Sometimes useful for macOS dialogs | Requires accessibility permissions on host; unreliable for simulator internals | ✗ NOT VERIFIED |
+| `cliclick` (current approach) | coordinate-based mouse clicks | No install | Fragile (window-position dependent); not accessibility-aware | ✗ SUPERSEDED |
+| Private CoreSimulator APIs | anything | Low-level control | Undocumented; breaks on Xcode updates | ✗ NOT ATTEMPTED |
+
+---
+
+## Install Instructions
+
+### One-time setup
+
+```bash
+# 1. Install idb_companion via Homebrew
+brew tap facebook/fb
+brew install idb-companion
+
+# 2. Install idb Python CLI in a Python 3.12 venv
+#    (the client has asyncio compatibility issues with Python 3.14+)
+python3.12 -m venv /opt/idb-venv
+/opt/idb-venv/bin/pip install fb-idb
+
+# Verify
+idb_companion --version   # prints build date JSON
+/opt/idb-venv/bin/idb --help
+```
+
+### Per-session setup (start the companion)
+
+```bash
+SIM="062F8F0A-B3E5-4A4B-BC8A-B01E98CF27F2"
+IDB="/opt/idb-venv/bin/idb"
+
+# Start idb_companion in the background
+idb_companion --udid $SIM &>/tmp/idb-companion.log &
+
+# Connect the idb client to it
+$IDB connect localhost 10882
+
+# Verify
+$IDB list-targets | grep $SIM
+```
+
+---
+
+## Recipes: 7 Verified Primitives
+
+### 1. Tap a button by accessibility label
+
+```bash
+# Helper function: find element by AXLabel, compute center, tap it
+tap_by_label() {
+  local label="$1"
+  local coords
+  coords=$($IDB ui describe-all --udid $SIM | python3 -c "
+import json, sys
+data = json.load(sys.stdin)
+for el in data:
+    if el.get('AXLabel') == '''$label''' or el.get('AXUniqueId') == '''$label''':
+        f = el['frame']
+        cx = f['x'] + f['width']/2
+        cy = f['y'] + f['height']/2
+        print(f'{cx:.0f} {cy:.0f}')
+        break
+")
+  if [ -z "$coords" ]; then
+    echo "ERROR: element '$label' not found" >&2
+    return 1
+  fi
+  local x; x=$(echo "$coords" | cut -d' ' -f1)
+  local y; y=$(echo "$coords" | cut -d' ' -f2)
+  echo "Tapping '$label' at ($x, $y)"
+  $IDB ui tap --udid $SIM "$x" "$y"
+}
+
+# Example: tap the Settings button
+tap_by_label "Settings"
+# → opens the Settings sheet ✓
+
+# Tap Done to dismiss it
+tap_by_label "Done"
+```
+
+**Evidence:** `02-after-settings-tap.png` (Settings sheet opened after tap).
+
+### 2. Type text into a focused field
+
+```bash
+# Tap the text area / input field first to give it focus
+$IDB ui tap --udid $SIM 187 400        # tap center of terminal text area
+
+# Type text
+$IDB ui text --udid $SIM "echo hello_idb_test"
+
+# Press Enter (HID keycode 40 = Return)
+$IDB ui key --udid $SIM 40
+```
+
+**Note:** `idb ui text` types the literal string. It does **not** need a system
+keyboard — it injects characters directly via accessibility. Special characters
+are supported as-is (no escaping needed for most printable ASCII).
+
+**Evidence:** `05-after-type.png` shows "echo hello_idb_test" in the terminal
+input; `08-after-swipe.png` shows "hello_idb_test" printed as output after
+Enter.
+
+### 3. Swipe / scroll
+
+```bash
+# Syntax: idb ui swipe x_start y_start x_end y_end [--duration <s>] [--delta <px>]
+
+# Scroll DOWN (swipe up): from (187,600) to (187,200)
+$IDB ui swipe --udid $SIM 187 600 187 200
+
+# Scroll UP (swipe down):
+$IDB ui swipe --udid $SIM 187 200 187 600
+
+# Swipe left (navigate back):
+$IDB ui swipe --udid $SIM 20 400 300 400
+
+# Slow swipe (for drag interactions):
+$IDB ui swipe --udid $SIM 187 600 187 200 --duration 0.8
+```
+
+**Evidence:** `07-before-swipe.png` → `08-after-swipe.png` shows the terminal
+view scrolled to reveal earlier output.
+
+### 4. Assert that a view / text is visible
+
+idb exposes the full iOS accessibility tree. Two levels of assertions:
+
+#### 4a. Assert element exists by label
+
+```bash
+assert_visible() {
+  local label="$1"
+  local found
+  found=$($IDB ui describe-all --udid $SIM | python3 -c "
+import json, sys
+data = json.load(sys.stdin)
+for el in data:
+    if el.get('AXLabel') == '''$label''' or el.get('AXUniqueId') == '''$label''':
+        print('found')
+        break
+")
+  if [ "$found" = "found" ]; then
+    echo "✓ '$label' is visible"
+    return 0
+  else
+    echo "✗ '$label' not visible"
+    return 1
+  fi
+}
+
+assert_visible "Settings"    # → ✓ 'Settings' is visible
+assert_visible "Nonexistent" # → ✗ 'Nonexistent' not visible
+```
+
+#### 4b. Assert TextArea content (app-specific limitation)
+
+piRemote renders the terminal using SwiftTerm's custom drawing (not UIKit
+`UILabel`s), so the `AXValue` of the TextArea node is always empty. Text shown
+in the terminal is **not** accessible via the accessibility tree.
+
+**Workaround:** Take a screenshot and process it with OCR, or check app-layer
+state directly (e.g. via Sidecar's REST API for piRemote specifically).
+
+For apps using standard UIKit `UILabel`/`UITextField`, `AXLabel` or `AXValue`
+will contain the text and `assert_visible` above works perfectly.
+
+### 5. Screenshot tied to a specific UI element
+
+```bash
+# Full screenshot
+$IDB screenshot --udid $SIM /tmp/before.png
+
+# Element-scoped crop: find element frame → crop with sips
+element_screenshot() {
+  local label="$1"
+  local out="$2"
+  local scale=3  # iPhone 12 mini @3x
+
+  local info
+  info=$($IDB ui describe-all --udid $SIM | python3 -c "
+import json, sys
+data = json.load(sys.stdin)
+for el in data:
+    if el.get('AXLabel') == '''$label''' or el.get('AXUniqueId') == '''$label''':
+        f = el['frame']
+        pad = 10
+        print(int((f['y']-pad)*$scale),  # offsetY
+              int((f['x']-pad)*$scale),  # offsetX
+              int((f['height']+2*pad)*$scale),  # cropH
+              int((f['width']+2*pad)*$scale))   # cropW
+        break
+")
+  local oy ox ch cw
+  read -r oy ox ch cw <<< "$info"
+  $IDB screenshot --udid $SIM /tmp/_elem_full.png
+  cp /tmp/_elem_full.png "$out"
+  sips "$out" --cropOffset "$oy" "$ox" --cropToHeightWidth "$ch" "$cw" &>/dev/null
+  echo "Saved element screenshot to $out"
+}
+
+element_screenshot "Settings" /tmp/settings-btn.png
+```
+
+### 6. Dismiss system alerts
+
+System alerts (permission dialogs, "Open in…" URL sheets, etc.) appear as
+normal elements in the accessibility tree. The universal pattern:
+
+```bash
+# Wait for and dismiss any alert with an "Allow" or "Open" button
+dismiss_alert() {
+  local timeout=${1:-5}
+  local elapsed=0
+  while [ $elapsed -lt $timeout ]; do
+    local coords
+    coords=$($IDB ui describe-all --udid $SIM | python3 -c "
+import json, sys
+data = json.load(sys.stdin)
+for el in data:
+    label = el.get('AXLabel') or ''
+    if label in ('Allow', 'Allow Once', 'Allow While Using App',
+                 'Open', 'OK', 'Continue', 'Don\\'t Allow'):
+        f = el['frame']
+        print(f\"{f['x']+f['width']/2:.0f} {f['y']+f['height']/2:.0f}\")
+        break
+" 2>/dev/null)
+    if [ -n "$coords" ]; then
+      x=$(echo "$coords" | cut -d' ' -f1)
+      y=$(echo "$coords" | cut -d' ' -f2)
+      $IDB ui tap --udid $SIM "$x" "$y"
+      echo "Alert dismissed"
+      return 0
+    fi
+    sleep 0.5
+    elapsed=$((elapsed + 1))
+  done
+  echo "No alert found within ${timeout}s"
+  return 1
+}
+```
+
+**For pre-emptive dismissal** (avoid the dialog entirely):
+
+```bash
+# Grant permissions before the app asks, suppressing the dialog
+xcrun simctl privacy $SIM grant notifications de.vpsj.pi-remote
+xcrun simctl privacy $SIM grant photos de.vpsj.pi-remote
+xcrun simctl privacy $SIM grant location de.vpsj.pi-remote
+```
+
+**Verified behavior:** When an iOS pop-up/sheet is present, `idb ui
+describe-all` returns elements from within it. The Close button of the native
+iOS share sheet was found at `AXUniqueId: header.closeButton` and successfully
+tapped.
+
+### 7. Trigger deep links — no confirm prompt
+
+```bash
+# xcrun simctl openurl talks directly to SpringBoard, bypassing the
+# "Open in piRemote?" confirmation prompt that Safari would show.
+xcrun simctl openurl $SIM "pi-remote://test"
+```
+
+This was **verified** to open piRemote immediately without any system dialog.
+
+The confirm prompt only appears when a URL is navigated to inside another app
+(e.g. Safari). If you need to test the prompt itself:
+1. Open Safari: `xcrun simctl openurl $SIM "https://example.com"`
+2. Use `tap_by_label "Address"` → type the URL → press Enter
+3. Wait for the alert → use `dismiss_alert` above
+
+**Verified:** `33-deeplink-no-prompt.png` shows piRemote active after
+`xcrun simctl openurl`, with no intermediate dialog.
+
+---
+
+## Complete Worked Example
+
+Launch app → tap Settings → verify it opens → dismiss → type a command →
+submit → verify output (via screenshot).
+
+```bash
+#!/usr/bin/env bash
+set -euo pipefail
+
+SIM="062F8F0A-B3E5-4A4B-BC8A-B01E98CF27F2"
+APP="de.vpsj.pi-remote"
+IDB="/opt/idb-venv/bin/idb"
+EVIDENCE="/tmp/sim-run-$(date +%Y%m%d-%H%M%S)"
+mkdir -p "$EVIDENCE"
+
+# ── 0. Start companion (idempotent) ────────────────────────────────────────
+pkill idb_companion 2>/dev/null || true
+idb_companion --udid "$SIM" &>/tmp/idb-companion.log &
+sleep 2
+$IDB connect localhost 10882
+
+# ── 1. Launch app ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
+xcrun simctl launch "$SIM" "$APP"
+sleep 2
+
+$IDB screenshot --udid "$SIM" "$EVIDENCE/01-launched.png"
+echo "✓ App launched"
+
+# ── 2. Tap Settings button ─────────────────────────────────────────────────
+tap_by_label() {
+  local label="$1"
+  local coords
+  coords=$($IDB ui describe-all --udid "$SIM" | python3 -c "
+import json, sys
+data = json.load(sys.stdin)
+for el in data:
+    if el.get('AXLabel') == '$label' or el.get('AXUniqueId') == '$label':
+        f = el['frame']
+        print(f\"{f['x']+f['width']/2:.0f} {f['y']+f['height']/2:.0f}\")
+        break
+")
+  [ -z "$coords" ] && { echo "ERROR: '$label' not found" >&2; return 1; }
+  $IDB ui tap --udid "$SIM" $(echo "$coords" | tr ' ' '\n')
+}
+
+tap_by_label "Settings"
+sleep 1
+$IDB screenshot --udid "$SIM" "$EVIDENCE/02-settings-open.png"
+
+# Assert Settings sheet is showing
+$IDB ui describe-all --udid "$SIM" | python3 -c "
+import json, sys
+data = json.load(sys.stdin)
+assert any(el.get('AXLabel') == 'Done' for el in data), 'Settings sheet not open!'
+print('✓ Settings sheet is visible (Done button found)')
+"
+
+# ── 3. Dismiss Settings ────────────────────────────────────────────────────
+tap_by_label "Done"
+sleep 0.5
+echo "✓ Settings dismissed"
+
+# ── 4. Type a command and submit ───────────────────────────────────────────
+$IDB ui tap --udid "$SIM" 187 400   # focus terminal text area
+$IDB ui text --udid "$SIM" "echo hello_idb_test"
+$IDB screenshot --udid "$SIM" "$EVIDENCE/03-typed.png"
+$IDB ui key --udid "$SIM" 40        # Return
+sleep 1
+
+$IDB screenshot --udid "$SIM" "$EVIDENCE/04-submitted.png"
+echo "✓ Command typed and submitted"
+
+# ── 5. Verify via screenshot (visual) ──────────────────────────────────────
+echo "✓ Check $EVIDENCE/04-submitted.png — 'hello_idb_test' should be visible in terminal"
+```
+
+### Screenshots from verified run
+
+| Step | Screenshot |
+|---|---|
+| Before tap | ![before tap](sim-automation-evidence/01-before-settings-tap.png) |
+| After tapping Settings | ![settings open](sim-automation-evidence/02-after-settings-tap.png) |
+| Before typing | ![before type](sim-automation-evidence/04-before-type.png) |
+| After typing "echo hello_idb_test" | ![after type](sim-automation-evidence/05-after-type.png) |
+| Before scroll | ![before swipe](sim-automation-evidence/07-before-swipe.png) |
+| After scroll (shows "hello_idb_test" output) | ![after swipe](sim-automation-evidence/08-after-swipe.png) |
+| Deep link — no prompt | ![deep link](sim-automation-evidence/33-deeplink-no-prompt.png) |
+
+---
+
+## Known Gotchas
+
+### 1. Python version for idb CLI
+
+`idb` (the Python client) uses `asyncio.get_event_loop()` which was deprecated
+in Python 3.10 and raises `RuntimeError` in 3.14. **Always run it from a
+Python 3.12 venv:**
+
+```bash
+python3.12 -m venv /opt/idb-venv
+/opt/idb-venv/bin/pip install fb-idb
+```
+
+### 2. idb_companion must be started first
+
+The `idb_companion` process acts as a gRPC server for the simulator. Start it
+before any `idb` client calls:
+
+```bash
+idb_companion --udid $SIM &>/tmp/idb.log &
+sleep 2
+idb connect localhost 10882
+```
+
+If you forget, `idb` commands silently return empty results.
+
+### 3. Terminal text not in accessibility tree
+
+piRemote's terminal (SwiftTerm) renders text via CoreText/Metal, not via
+`UILabel`. Therefore `idb ui describe-all` returns an empty `AXValue` for the
+terminal's `TextArea` node. You cannot assert terminal text content via
+accessibility.
+
+**Workarounds:**
+- Visual: compare screenshots (e.g. use `tesseract` or `mlx_vlm` for OCR)
+- Programmatic: query Sidecar's REST API (`http://10.13.37.2:17373`)
+- Add an `accessibilityValue` to the SwiftTerm view (requires source change)
+
+### 4. URL-scheme confirm prompt
+
+`xcrun simctl openurl` routes through SpringBoard directly and **never** shows
+a "Open in piRemote?" confirmation. That prompt only appears when:
+- Safari (or another app) navigates to the custom URL scheme
+- There are multiple apps registered for the scheme
+
+In the simulator there is usually only one app per scheme, so even Safari
+navigating to `pi-remote://` opens it promptly. If you do need to test the
+confirmation dialog, open a page in Safari that links to the URL scheme (using
+an HTML `<a>` tag) and tap the link.
+
+### 5. `xcrun simctl privacy` requires Booted sim
+
+The `privacy grant/revoke` subcommand fails with "Operation not permitted" on
+some protected services (e.g. notifications). Use `privacy reset` to force
+re-prompting or `privacy grant` for services that support it (photos, location,
+contacts, microphone, etc.).
+
+### 6. Simulator must be focused / visible for some touch events
+
+idb injects events through the Simulator framework (not host-OS mouse clicks),
+so the simulator window does **not** need to be in the foreground. Events work
+even when another macOS window is on top.
+
+### 7. `describe-all` returns flattened, not nested tree
+
+The output of `idb ui describe-all` is a flat JSON array. Parent/child
+relationships are not directly encoded. If two elements have the same `AXLabel`,
+sort by proximity to expected coordinates.
+
+### 8. idb_companion version vs Xcode version mismatch
+
+Homebrew's `idb_companion` was built against an older Xcode (Aug 2022). On
+Xcode 16.4 it still works for all tested operations but may miss newer
+simulator features. The warning about "Xcode 16.4 being outdated" is from
+Homebrew's Tier 2 support and can be ignored.
+
+---
+
+## What Was NOT Verified
+
+| Feature | Status |
+|---|---|
+| XCUITest via `xcodebuild test` | Not tested — requires adding a test target (source change) |
+| WebDriverAgent / Appium | Not tested — complex setup; overkill for shell-based automation |
+| AppleScript + System Events | Not tested — requires granting host-OS accessibility; slow |
+| `idb ui describe-point` for filled coordinates | Partially — returns empty element when no accessible element exists at exact point |
+| Terminal text assertion via accessibility | Does NOT work — custom renderer |
+| `xcrun simctl privacy` for notifications | Fails on iOS 18.6 with "Operation not permitted" |
+| URL scheme confirm prompt via Safari link click | Triggers SpringBoard directly with no prompt in practice on iOS 18 sim |